I originally started writing this as part of my Am I Using the Best Homeschool Curriculum post. I quickly realized that I had a lot to say on this topic and it deserved its own post. If you have been in the homeschool world for all of a minute, you have probably heard of The Good and the Beautiful.

In Christian homeschool circles, any mention of The Good and the Beautiful usually comes with a warning. Here is what I originally wrote for my other post (go read it for context).

“I heard the writer is a Mormon and I’m pretty sure she eats babies. I have never seen any religious content or baby eating in the curriculum, but if you use it your children might not go to Heaven.”

While the above is meant to be a complete exaggeration, it does illustrate how ridiculous I feel the controversy is over this curriculum. I will dive into what started the controversy a little bit later in this post, but for now I want to talk about whether or not it is okay for Christians to use The Good and the Beautiful or any other non-Christian curriculum.

Before I get started on my rant, um I mean post, I do want to give a little disclaimer. I am a full-fledged, born again, Bible reading, church going, evangelical Christian.

While the LDS (Mormon) church also uses the Christian label, I acknowledge that our beliefs differ greatly. I’m talking big, fundamental differences. Okay, now with that disclaimer out of the way, here we go.

This post contains affiliate links and My Homeschool with a View, LLC participates in the Amazon Associates program. If you make a qualifying purchase through our links, we earn a commission at no additional cost to you . Thank you for supporting this site! You can read my affiliate and advertising disclosure here.

It’s Okay for Christians to Eat Secular Groceries

Alright, this heading is a little strange and seems off topic, but stay with me for a minute. I like to shop at Costco. It is probably my favorite store. I love that I can buy my entire wardrobe, shoes for my kids, and groceries all while snacking on delicious food samples.

And I can buy toilet paper in bulk. This proved very valuable in the spring of 2020.

The items I buy in the store have a large impact on my family. These items nourish and clothe the bodies of my children. I would say Costco plays an important role in our lives.

Do you know what religious beliefs the Costco CEO holds? Neither do I. Not a clue.

I have no idea where the manufacturers of the bulk toilet paper go to church. Should I stop shopping at Costco because of this? No, it would be ridiculous to base my grocery buying solely on the beleifs of another person.

In this same way, I don’t think it’s necessary for Christians to avoid curriculum from authors and publishers who have differing beliefs. While I would never hand over a resource to my kids that teaches something in direct conflict with our faith, I don’t think the differing beliefs of a publisher should make a curriculum off limits.

This is a matter of personal choice and it’s not something any influencer or blogger or competing publisher (more on that later) should decide for you.

Homeschool Curriculum is a Tool

Have you ever used Mormon scissors? How about a Catholic hammer? I once felt convicted and threw away my Jehovah’s Witness screw driver.

Does this sound ridiculous to you? Of course it does. A tool is just a tool.

If you are letting a tool be the spiritual leader or influencer in your child’s life, then there is a whole lot of reevaluating that needs to happen.

Homeschool curriculum, while super helpful and something I am very grateful for, is just a tool. It is a helper for homeschool moms to give their kids an academic foundation.

Homeschool Curriculum is not Responsible for Spiritual Upbringing

If you spend a hot minute choosing homeschool curiculum, you will see many marketing gimmicks. I have even seen a publisher advertise a spiritual growth guarantee attached to their curriculum.

This made me cringe every time I read it. It was basically, if your child doesn’t grow spiritually after using our curriculum, we’ll refund your money. If you don’t find that statement cringe worthy, read it a few times until it sinks in.

Is it the rightful place of any homeschool curriculum to guide your child’s spiritual growth? No. As parents, it is our job to guide them so they can develop their own spiritual lives.

A curriculum that claims to take that responsiblity for you is using a marketing gimmick to sell more books. As an entrpreneur I don’t blame them. As a Christian homeschool mom, it bothers me.

If you have nothing but a Bible to teach your kids about God, that is enough. You don’t need a spiritually strong curriculum to do this for you.

I have experienced shaky theology even in what people consider to be very godly curriculum. God’s Word is completely trustworthy. Curriculum is not, no matter how great or Biblical it is advertised to be.

Consider the Source

At the beginning of this post, I said I would get into what started The Good and the Beautiful controversy. Basically, a popular homeschool blogger that used and endorsed The Good and The Beautiful Curriculum stopped using it and made a video announcing why.

The reasons seemed to be dripping with self-righteousness, but whatever. I am not easily influenced by Christians who tell me how I should behave or act in order to be a good Christian.

I actually didn’t take issue with her giving her opinion. The internet is full of opinions, and as information consumers it is important to have discernment of the opinions we listen to.

Shortly after starting the controversy, the blogger came out with her own, competing curriculum. A lot of people found the timing suspicious.

Opinions are great. This post is admittedly very opinionated. It’s always important to consider the source of the opinion and if they have something to gain, especially when it’s financial gain.

We should never take a person’s opinion as gospel. The internet is great for ideas, but don’t give influencers, publishers or bloggers (including me) a bigger place in your life than what is deserved.

Why Did I Write this Post?

I have no relationship with The Good and The Beautiful. I don’t even use the curriculum, but have come close to choosing it several times. The free Language Arts has been downloaded to my computer for a couple years but I ended up using other things.

The only reason I decided to write this post is because I don’t think Christian homeschool moms should feel guilty for using what works for their kids. You don’t need a spiritually superior or the most godly curriculum to influence your kids. That’s what you are for.

If a curriculum works for your kids and you love it, that’s awesome and that’s enough reason to like it. It is okay to use a curriculum solely for the academic benefit. That is its purpose.

My View of The Good and the Beautiful Controversy

When I originally wrote this post, I had never even used The Good and the Beautiful curriculum. I just knew of the controversy and added my opinion.

I have now used parts of this curriculum for a few years, and my opinion is still the same. It is a beautiful homeschool curriculum.

While acknowledging the differing beliefs I have from the publisher, I think it is important to also acknowledge the goodness that has come from this company. I don’t know of another homeschool curriculum publisher that offers as many free resources as The Good and the Beautiful.

Many homeschool familes give up a second income in order to homeschool which limits homeschool budgets. I appreciate a company that provides high quality resources to families that might have to otherwise make educational compromises.

Instead of fighting over which homeschool company is better, or spiritually superior, let’s encourage eachother to homeschool strong.

FAQs About The Good and the Beautiful Curriculum for Christian Homeschoolers

1. Is The Good and the Beautiful curriculum suitable for Christian homeschooling? Absolutely! The Good and the Beautiful curriculum is designed to be adaptable to various educational philosophies, including Christian homeschooling. While the curriculum itself is not overtly doctrinal, it offers flexibility for families to integrate their faith into their lessons.

2. Are there any religious components in The Good and the Beautiful curriculum? The Good and the Beautiful curriculum has a religious worldview. It does incorporate moral and character-building themes that align with many Christian values.

3. How does The Good and the Beautiful curriculum compare to explicitly Christian homeschooling curricula? While explicitly Christian homeschooling curricula may include extensive theological or doctrinal content and Bible study materials, The Good and the Beautiful curriculum focuses more on academic subjects with an emphasis on character development. Families seeking a balance between academic rigor and faith-based instruction may find The Good and the Beautiful curriculum to be a suitable option.

4. How can I address concerns about using a curriculum created by individuals with different religious beliefs? It’s essential to approach curriculum selection with discernment. While the creators of The Good and the Beautiful curriculum may have differing religious beliefs, many Christian homeschoolers find value in the curriculum’s academic quality and flexibility. Ultimately, each family must consider whether the curriculum aligns with their household and educational goals.

5. Is The Good and the Beautiful curriculum compatible with a Christian worldview? Yes, many Christian homeschoolers appreciate The Good and the Beautiful curriculum’s emphasis on wholesome literature, character development, and values-based learning.